Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Boromir88]

Nerwen, no Day 1 vote, and said why. No reason to not believe it, something came up, doesn't make her look like a wolf, nor like an innocent.

Day 2:

Looking at who Nerwen said she cross-posted with, she cross-voted with Brinn's (voted for sally) and Mac's (voted for Gwath). When Nerwen cast her vote the situation was:

Nogrod - 3
Gwath - 2
McCaber - 2
Sally - 1
Boro - 1

Brinn gives sally a 2nd vote, Mac ties it up between Nogrod and Gwath, and Nerwen gives me a 2nd vote...all right at the end. (Nogrod saves himself, but I don't know if he crossed with anyone or not, that doesn't matter).

I disagree with Mac that Nerwen's day 2 vote looks suspicious. Nerwen looks like she got stuck in the situation that I was in at the end of Day 1. Nerwen admits it was a throw away, because the situation was coming down between Gwath and Nogrod, it would then appear Nerwen was trying to pass the responsibility to somebody else. But, previously (in post 238) she just says she doesn't know what to think. She didn't like Gwath's response to Rikae, but didn't like Mith and Nogrod's jump on Gwath. She also marks she doesn't like the way I went after Lalwende after she had been testing Lal and concluded Lal was not a wolf.

The way Nerwen goes after the "bandwagoners" who are quick to follow someone else is consistent.

Day 3:

When Nerwen votes for me, she crosses with McCaber's vote for sally, and Mith's vote for Lal.

So the situation was...

Nogrod - 2
Mith - 2
sally - 1
Lal - 1

Nerwen adds me to the list, while sally and Lal both receive their 2nd votes. I'm not quite sure what to make of this. Sally was a wolf, and if Nerwen's a wolf, why would she spread the vote more? Why wouldn't she try to create some distance for sally? I mean she did have Lal (the believed cobbler) to sacrifice if needed, to try and create a diversion/get sally out of focus. Spreading the vote in that situation doesn't make sense for a wolf.

Also, sally's response to Nerwen's vote:

Again. Confused. Adding another candidate this close to deadline never makes me happy. (Unless he DOES have a previous vote and I missed it, in which case mildly disregard this comment)

Now, would wolf sally point this out to a wolf-Nerwen. Possibly, she did react to CoD's Day 1 vote, but then she went on to defend him. Plus, her reaction to CoD, looked like an over-reaction (looked fake), I wouldn't call this an over-reaction. Still the question is, because I don't know, would sally point that out if Nerwen was a wolf too?

Day 4:

Doesn't cross-vote with anyone, votes for Lal, tying her up with me.
The question I have for you Nerwen, is I see you mention that if Nogrod was right, than I at most am the cobbler, where Lal could be a wolf. Now that does lie consistent with your approach in this village, wanting to vote for a wolf first, rather than shoot for the cobbler. But how did you decide that Lal could be a wolf, when the days before you said you reached the conclusion she wasn't furry?