WW LXXV: It's Always Tea Time Here

[Nogrod]

(~~~) *grin appearing after vanishing for good*

Originally Posted by Inziladun

I would prefer to vote for Mira, or maybe someone who now looks just as bad to me, Greenie, with her votes for Lottie (Day 1), Shasta (Day 2), and now Nog (Day 3).

I don't know about Mira. I can see why she looks suspicious and I kind of share the feeling, but I haven't had time to check her, so I'm quite undecided with her. If you guys think there are good reasons to lynch her then do it. I just don't have time to dwell into that myself toDay.

There are enough votes to come to lynch anyone.

But I would say I find Greenie quite innocentish. Her explanations on D1 felt quite honest and true and even if she has managed to fool me big time a few times I still have a gut feeling she's not a baddie. As Lommy said, she tends to suspect me everytime we play so I can't say her suspicion on me was that great a surprise (and actually I can't blame her for voting Shasta either). Also, as I said earlier, she tends to like being the individual-minded, "not going with the flow" player, so I would be more surprised if she started bandwagoning...

(~~~) *grin vanishing for good the second time*

[Nienna]

Zil you are worried about lynching Glirdy without him being around but want to lynch Mira who is equally un-around. Of the two I think Glirdy looks much worse than Mira.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Nienna

Zil you are worried about lynching Glirdy without him being around but want to lynch Mira who is equally un-around. Of the two I think Glirdy looks much worse than Mira.

The difference is that the things I suspected Mira for she's had an opportunity to address. That's not the case with Glirdan.
It seems it's a moot point anyway, as it looks like it's going to be Glirdan toDay.

[Inziladun]

Oh well. Since everyone else is going with this:

++Glirdan

Better him than me, anyway.

[Loslote]

Okay, comments so far:

Don't lynch Zil, Shasta, or Nog, kthnxbye. I would be happy with either a Glirdy or a Greenie lynch, and as Glirdy looks more likely...

++Glirdy

Especially for his throwaway Shasta vote on Day 1 and for his continued suspicious behavior yesterDay.

[Nienna]

*wonders where everyone is...*

It is getting awfully close to deadline for no-one to be around...

Day 3
Morsul -> Glirdan
Brinn -> Glirdan (2)
Greenie -> Nogrod
Legate -> Inzil
Agan -> Inzil (2)
Lommy -> Glirdan (3)
Skip -> Shasta
Shasta -> Greenie
Nog -> Glirdan (4)
Zil -> Glirdan (5)
Lottie -> Glirdan (6)

Left to vote:
Glirdan
Mira
WinWin
Nerwen
Nienna

Crossed with Lottie's vote, updated

[Loslote]

Trust:
me

Mostly trust:
Legate
Lommy
Shasta
Nog
Zil
Nerwen
Nienna

Sort of trust:
Morsul
Brinn
Agan
Skip
WW

Suspect:
Greenie
Glirdan
Mira

And yes, I now suspect Mira...turns out she's playing and I'd pretty much forgotten.

Seriously, though, if I'm still alive toMorrow, she'd be a good one to look at. As will Greenie, of course.

And yes, I will be very vexed if you lynch any of my "mostly trust" list and they are innocent. Very, very vexed.

EDIT: Ah, xed, lovely.

[Inziladun]

I'm here. Who hasn't voted?

EDIT-just saw Nienna's vote count above

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Sally and Glirdy bantering there in the beginning was mainly based on IC and I do find Glirdy's style of play or approach quite suspicious basically everytime I play with him.

Same here– I've played several games with him and he's always like this, whatever his role. That's why I've been hesitating...

Originally Posted by Nogrod

But as my main effort toDay was looking at the votes and how they would come out whether Glirdy was innocent or a wolf I just can't let go of that mindset now. I'd have a much clearer view on things if I knew what was his alignment. As sad as it is to say, we can afford a mislynch now as we are 13 against 3, but being honest, I do think we have better chances of getting a wolf by lynching Glirdan than with many others.

And just to sum up my ideas if I'm not here to share them toMorrow:

- if Glirdan is lynched and he turns out innocent, it would mean that:
Lommy looks somewhat bad.
skip (add also his staunch defence of Glirdy which could be trying to barr the revealment of his innocence) and Inzil would look quite bad.

....Err, yes– but what will you think if Glirdan turns out guilty? Isn't this like saying "Heads Skip's furry, tails he's a wolf?"

Anyway–

++Glirdan

EDIT:X'd with Nienna; wording.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Skip is starting to worry me. First he insisted Glirdan was an active part of lynching Sally (which he wasn't), now he's questioning people's motives to vote him and considering the suspicions against him weak. I think I at least have pretty much evidence already, all his interactions with Sally yesterDay plus the things I mentioned in my vote post yesterDay. (I don't get it why it was bad reasoning for a vote. I thought it made a lot of sense, and I had elaborated on most of the points earlier in my long analysis post.) And then on top of that Skip concludes he is not sure about Glirdan, but he's not his top suspect. Fishy. .

It may simply be that Skip, as a newbie, just sees things differently... maybe doesn't really understand what we're talking about when we say someone's "acting wolfish", e.t.c.

That said, it's indeed interesting how persistent Skip has been toDay– trying one approach after another to defend Glirdy– first he was "proactively participating in lynching Sally" (#438), then the suspicion against him comes out of nowhere and "there isn't much weight behind the Glirdan accusers" (#498), then it's statistically more likely he's innocent(?!) (#504), then Sally would have only listed one wolf in her"suspect" list, so it's "Shasta, possibly" (#509). (And then he votes Shasta on very weak grounds.)

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Nerwen is also starting to worry me. The current situation looks awfully much to me like Sally and Glirdy are two of her fellows and she's doing some pretty drastic moves to make herself look good. I don't have any factual arguments, but somehow the calm rationality in which she presented/presents points against them makes me feel that she knows more than us others, and it's quite disturbing...

I don't, though.

EDIT:X'd with Loslote and Nienna.
EDIT2:added comment.