20 Questions on ME

[Firefoot]

Object?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes

[Firefoot]

Was it lost with Númenor?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Was it a weapon?

[Gil-Galad]

Was it Highly Coveted?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably

[Firefoot]

Owned by a king/queen?

[rutslegolas]

Was it Owned by the Elves ? ?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No

[Firefoot]

Does it have a proper name?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No
Does it have a proper name? Yes

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Was it Palarran?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No
Was it Palarran? No

[Firefoot]

The Bough of Return?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No
Was it Palarran? No
The Bough of Return? No

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

In Númenor?

[Gil-Galad]

Devised in Numenor?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No
Was it Palarran? No
The Bough of Return? No
In Númenor? Mostly No
Devised in Numenor? Yes (which is why the above is mostly and not entirely)

[Firefoot]

Owned by Aldarion?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

A ship?

[Lindolirian]

Third Age? No
First Age? No
Second Age? Yes
Event? No
Place? No
Living? No
Object? Yes
Lost with Numenor? Most likely ceased to exist before the Drowning
Was it a weapon? No
Was if Highly Coveted? Probably
Owned by a king/queen? Yes
Was it Owned by the Elves? No
Was it Palarran? No
The Bough of Return? No
In Númenor? Mostly No
Devised in Numenor? Yes (which is why the above is mostly and not entirely)
Owned by Aldarion? Yes
A ship? Yes

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Is it Numerramar ?

[Celegorm]

Hirilondë?

[Lindolirian]

That's the one... you're up. :)

[Firefoot]

Third Age?

[Celegorm]

:)

Third Age? Yes

[Firefoot]

Living?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No

[Firefoot]

Object?

[Gil-Galad]

Weapon?


Building?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

A place?

[Evisse the Blue]

Event?

[Mithalwen]

Undead?

[Vinyacoriel]

did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship? Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.

[Gil-Galad]

gift?

[Vinyacoriel]

does it have a proper name?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No

[Vinyacoriel]

West of the Misty Mountains?

[Firefoot]

Owned by a Man?

[Gil-Galad]

made before third age?

[Evisse the Blue]

Owned by anyone?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Clothing?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No

[Firefoot]

Jewelry of some type?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No
Jewelry of some type? No

[Firefoot]

Owned by a Hobbit?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

An article of clothing?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Owned by an elf?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No
Jewelry of some type? No
Owned by a Hobbit? Yes
An article of clothing? No
Owned by an elf? No

[Firefoot]

Belong to Bilbo?

[Celegorm]

Belong to Bilbo? Yes

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Bilbo's map of Erebor?

[Celegorm]

Bilbo's map of Erebor? No

[Gil-Galad]

aquired after Bilbos first adventure?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No
Jewelry of some type? No
Owned by a Hobbit? Yes
An article of clothing? No
Owned by an elf? No
Belong to Bilbo? Yes
Bilbo's map of Erebor? No
aquired after Bilbos first adventure? No

[Firefoot]

Was it gotten from Smaug's accumulated wealth?

[Lindolirian]

Was it the trolls' loot?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Was it acquired between Rivendell (including in Rivendell) and entering
Mirkwood?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Clothing was already asked.

Owned by anyone before Bilbo?

[Evisse the Blue]

Owned by anyone after Bilbo?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No
Jewelry of some type? No
Owned by a Hobbit? Yes
An article of clothing? No
Owned by an elf? No
Belong to Bilbo? Yes
Bilbo's map of Erebor? No
acquired after Bilbos first adventure? No
Was it gotten from Smaug's accumulated wealth? No
Was it the trolls' loot? No
Was it acquired between Rivendell (including in Rivendell) and entering
Mirkwood? No
Owned by anyone before Bilbo? Not mentioned, I would guess so.
Owned by anyone after Bilbo? Yes

[The Saucepan Man]

Was it one of Bilbo's leaving gifts?

If so, the silver spoons that he pointedly left for Lobelia Sackville-Baggins?

[Mithalwen]

Was it one of the keepsakes that Bilbo left as jokey presents for his family when he left Bag end?

[Celegorm]

Was it one of Bilbo's leaving gifts? Kind of that, but not mentioned as a gift.
If so, the silver spoons that he pointedly left for Lobelia Sackville-Baggins?
No

Was it one of the keepsakes that Bilbo left as jokey presents for his family when he left Bag end? No

[Firefoot]

Acquired on his journey?

[Evisse the Blue]

Was it taken to Frodo's house in Crickhollow?

[Celegorm]

Acquired on his journey? No
Was it taken to Frodo's house in Crickhollow? Possible, but rather not.

[Gil-Galad]

Owned by Frodo as well?

[Mithalwen]

His feather beds?

[Firefoot]

Mentioned in The Hobbit?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Related to Bilbo's wine holdings?

[Celegorm]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Object? Yes
Building? No
Weapon? No
A place? No
Event? No
Undead? No
did it come into contact with anyone who was in the fellowship?
Not realy mentioned, but I would guess so.
gift? Yes+No
does it have a proper name? No
West of the Misty Mountains? Yes
Owned by a Man? No
made before third age? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by anyone? Yes
Clothing? No
Jewelry of some type? No
Owned by a Hobbit? Yes
An article of clothing? No
Owned by an elf? No
Belong to Bilbo? Yes
Bilbo's map of Erebor? No
acquired after Bilbos first adventure? No
Was it gotten from Smaug's accumulated wealth? No
Was it the trolls' loot? No
Was it acquired between Rivendell (including in Rivendell) and entering
Mirkwood? No
Owned by anyone before Bilbo? Not mentioned, I would guess so.
Owned by anyone after Bilbo? Yes
Was it one of Bilbo's leaving gifts? Kind of that, but not mentioned as a gift.
If so, the silver spoons that he pointedly left for Lobelia Sackville-Baggins? No
Was it one of the keepsakes that Bilbo left as jokey presents for his family when he left Bag end? No
Acquired on his journey? No
Was it taken to Frodo's house in Crickhollow? Possible, but rather not.
Owned by Frodo as well? Yes
His feather beds? No
Mentioned in The Hobbit? Yes
Related to Bilbo's wine holdings? No

[The Saucepan Man]

The door to Bag End?

[Celegorm]

The door to Bag End? Nope

[Gil-Galad]

Did Frodo aqquire it after Bilbo left?

[Firefoot]

A piece of furniture?

[Celegorm]

Did Frodo aqquire it after Bilbo left? Hm, how should Bilbo own it then? NO!
A piece of furniture? Yes!

[Lindolirian]

Bilbo's easy chair he always wished he was in? Listening to his tea pot whistle... not for the last time!

[Celegorm]

Bilbo's easy chair he always wished he was in? Listening to his tea pot whistle... not for the last time! No

[Firefoot]

The drawing-room couch where Bilbo revived after fainting during the Unexpected Party?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

The stone head of the king in the crossroads?

Wrong puzzle, stupid head!

Oh. Ignore title statement, then.

Can it fit in a bag?

[Celegorm]

The drawing-room couch where Bilbo revived after fainting during the Unexpected Party?No
Can it fit in a bag? That depends on the size of the bag... but more yes then no.

[Firefoot]

Is its purpose for sitting on (e.g. couch, chair, etc)?

[The Saucepan Man]

Hmm, if it is a piece of furniture, wouldn't it have been more likely than not to have been moved to Crickhollow?

Is it a fixture or fitting of Bag End?

If so, is it the hearth?

EDIT: Aha! Or the mantlepiece on which the Dwarves' letter was left?

(Sorry - very naughty to have two bites at the cherry, but I couldn't resist.)

[Celegorm]

Is its purpose for sitting on (e.g. couch, chair, etc)? No

Hmm, if it is a piece of furniture, wouldn't it have been more likely than not to have been moved to Crickhollow? Yes

Is it a fixture or fitting of Bag End? Lest's say, it has a fix place.

If so, is it the hearth? No

EDIT: Aha! Or the mantlepiece on which the Dwarves' letter was left? No

(Sorry - very naughty to have two bites at the cherry, but I couldn't resist.)Hm, four questions... bad boy...

[The Saucepan Man]

Hm, four questions... bad boy...I'd rather describe them as one comment, one question and two related guesses. ;)

But I'm finding these hard to reconcile:


Was it taken to Frodo's house in Crickhollow? Possible, but rather not.

A piece of furniture? Yes!

Hmm, if it is a piece of furniture, wouldn't it have been more likely than not to have been moved to Crickhollow? Yes

[Evisse the Blue]

The hanger?

[Firefoot]

The doorbell (is that furniture?)?

Found inside the parlor?

[Celegorm]

The hanger? No
The doorbell (is that furniture?)? No (?ask the Pan-Man...)
Found inside the parlor? Yes


But I'm finding these hard to reconcile:
Hmm, if it is a piece of furniture, wouldn't it have been more likely than not to have been moved to Crickhollow? Yes
Sorry, to confuse you. But what I meant is, there are a lot of things, he may have taken with him, but Frodo didn't left Bagend absolutly blank. It's not said, if he had taken this thing with him.

[Firefoot]

The footstool?

[Celegorm]

The footstool? Nope

[Eruanna]

The clock on the mantlepiece?

[Firefoot]

The table?

Running out of furniture, methinks.

[Celegorm]

The clock on the mantlepiece? No
The table? Which one? :rolleyes: - No, it's not a table

[Firefoot]

Sorry, it seemed to me after skimming the chapter several times that there was only one table in the parlor.

The poker and shovel for the fireplace?

[Celegorm]

Sorry, it seemed to me after skimming the chapter several times that there was only one table in the parlor. '...and before he could say knife they had whisked the trays and a couple of small tables into the parlour and set out everything afresh.'

The poker and shovel for the fireplace? No, but close...

[Firefoot]

I stand corrected.

The fender Bilbo accidentally sat on?

[Mithalwen]

The fire tongs that Gandalf uses to retrieve the ring from the fire at Bag End?

[Celegorm]

The Fender is right! :)

Go on Firefoot.

[Firefoot]

Thanks. :cool:

Start guessing!

[Vinyacoriel]

Third Age?

[Celegorm]

Living?


(There was still that lamp... NO, I'm not obsessed by light-things... :D )

[Gil-Galad]

First AGe?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

North of Rohan?

[Evisse the Blue]

Congrats, Firefoot! And congrats, Celegorm for thinking of such a tough one! ;)

Event?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No

[Gil-Galad]

Weapon?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No

Weapon? Yes

[Gil-Galad]

Elven-Made?

[Vinyacoriel]

Handled by any of the Fellowship?

[Celegorm]

A weapon with a blade?

[Mithalwen]

belonging to one of the "baddies" ?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No
Weapon? Yes

Elven-Made? No
Handled by any of the Fellowship? No
A weapon with a blade? No
belonging to one of the "baddies" ? Yes
A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)? No

[The Saucepan Man]

Does it have a name?

[Gil-Galad]

Unique?(only one or nine ever made? ;) )

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Owned, used, by nassty orcsees? :mad:

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No
Weapon? Yes
Elven-Made? No
Handled by any of the Fellowship? No
A weapon with a blade? No
belonging to one of the "baddies" ? Yes
A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)? No

Does it have a name? No
Unique?(only one or nine ever made? ;) ) Presumably not.
Owned, used, by nassty orcsees? :mad: No, Yes

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

A siege engine?

[Gil-Galad]

Created by Evil Man?

Created by Orcs?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

The whip used to drive Frodo and Sam when they were disguised as little orcs?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No
Weapon? Yes
Elven-Made? No
Handled by any of the Fellowship? No
A weapon with a blade? No
belonging to one of the "baddies" ? Yes
A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)? No
Does it have a name? No
Unique?(only one or nine ever made? ) Presumably not.
Owned, used, by nassty orcsees? No, Yes

A siege engine? No
Created by Evil Man? Not likely
Created by Orcs? Not likely
The whip used to drive Frodo and Sam when they were disguised as little orcs? No

[Eruanna]

One of the great catapults used by the orcs against Gondor?

[NightKnight]

Used at the Pelennor Fields?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No
Weapon? Yes
Elven-Made? No
Handled by any of the Fellowship? No
A weapon with a blade? No
belonging to one of the "baddies" ? Yes
A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)? No
Does it have a name? No
Unique?(only one or nine ever made? ) Presumably not.
Owned, used, by nassty orcsees? No, Yes
A siege engine? No
Created by Evil Man? Not likely
Created by Orcs? Not likely
The whip used to drive Frodo and Sam when they were disguised as little orcs? No

One of the great catapults used by the orcs against Gondor? No

[Celebriel Esgaledhel]

Used by the Valarauko?

[Evisse the Blue]

An arrow?

[Celegorm]

Was it made by someone?

[Vinyacoriel]

used in the battle of Helm's Deep?

[Firefoot]

Third Age? Yes
Living? No
First AGe? No
North of Rohan? No
Event? No
Weapon? Yes
Elven-Made? No
Handled by any of the Fellowship? No
A weapon with a blade? No
belonging to one of the "baddies" ? Yes
A weapon belonging to one of the Rohirric forces (including Merry)? No
Does it have a name? No
Unique?(only one or nine ever made? ) Presumably not.
Owned, used, by nassty orcsees? No, Yes
A siege engine? No
Created by Evil Man? Not likely
Created by Orcs? Not likely
The whip used to drive Frodo and Sam when they were disguised as little orcs? No
One of the great catapults used by the orcs against Gondor? No

Used by the Valarauko? No
An arrow? No
Was it made by someone? Yes (there is a "very probably" answer to this one...)
used in the battle of Helm's Deep? Yes

[Eruanna]

Ooo...is it 'The Devilry of Saruman' the gunpowder used to blow up the culvert beneath the gate at Helm's Deep?

[Firefoot]

Eruanna got it - it is indeed the Middle-earth-style bombs. ;)

[Evisse the Blue]

Congrats, Eruanna!

Is it living?

[Eruanna]

Thank you Firefoot, that last clue was the charm :)

Is it living? No

[Firefoot]

Third Age?

[Eruanna]

Third Age? Yes

[Lindolirian]

Object?

[Eruanna]

Object? Yes

[Lindolirian]

Owned by anyone?

[Firefoot]

1st Age?

[Gil-Galad]

Weapon?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Article of clothing?

[NightKnight]

Made by Elves?

[Evisse the Blue]

Does it have a specific name?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Used/owned by a hobbit?

[Eruanna]

Owned by anyone? Yes

First Age? No

Weapon? No

Article of clothing? Yes

Made by elves? No

Does it have a specific name? No

Used/owned by a hobbit? Yes/No

[Mithalwen]

So it was a garment borrowed by a hobbit from someone of another non-elvish race?

[Eruanna]

Yes :D

[Mithalwen]

Oh was it the hood and cloak that Bilbo borrowed from one of the dwarves? Dwalin I think...

[Eruanna]

Ta-Daa!
Mithalwen has it :)
It is indeed the old green hood and cloak that Dwalin loaned Bilbo; kept afterwards in a trunk at Bag-End.

Your turn :)

[Mithalwen]

Oh wow, this is exciting.... fire away :)

[Firefoot]

Third Age?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age?
Yes

[Lindolirian]

Living?

[Gil-Galad]

Unique?

[Firefoot]

Object?

[Vinyacoriel]

Proper name?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

An artificial structure?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr...

[Celebriel Esgaledhel]

Built by a Dwarf?

[Eruanna]

Built/made by elves?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf No

Any more? :D

[Celebriel Esgaledhel]

A natural object?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age Yes
Living No
Unique No
Object Yes
Proper name No
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf No
A natural object No

[Evisse the Blue]

Used by a man?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes

[Evisse the Blue]

Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan?

[Mithalwen]

Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan?
Yes
Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes

[Firefoot]

Used in battle?

And, I assume due to cross-posting based on times, you missed Eruanna's question, post #3412.

[Mithalwen]

Oh thanks Fire foot : I did indeed


Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes

* Indicates not known as fact but can reasonably be assumed to be the case on balance of probability, and if it isn't right then it is not material.

[Firefoot]

Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields?

[Vinyacoriel]

Used at the battle of Helm's Deep?

[Eruanna]

Is it a weapon?

[Vinyacoriel]

Built/made by orcs?

[Mithalwen]

So sorry, I tried to answer these using the internet phone at Waterloo station last night.. clearly it did not work... :o

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No

[Firefoot]

Used for defense?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes

[Firefoot]

Éowyn's shield?

Is it a shield?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes
Is it a shield? No

[Celegorm]

Made by man?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

A helmet?

[Mithalwen]

Third Age? Yes
Living No?
Unique No?
Object Yes?
Proper name No?
Artificial structure - errr... no?
Built by a dwarf? No
A natural object? No
Used by a Man? Yes
Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
Built/made by elves? No*
Used in battle? Yes
Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
Is it a weapon? No
Built/made by orcs? No
Used for defence? Yes
Is it a shield? No


Made by man? Yes
A helmet? No

Well that is the 20 gone..... ;)

[Eruanna]

The City Gate of Gondor?

[Mithalwen]

The City Gate of Gondor? Nope

[Lindolirian]

Was it exclusively defensive, or offensive as well?
:rolleyes: How about a "yes or no" Q:
Used for offense?

[Firefoot]

Is it used to protect a specific individual?

[Gil-Galad]

Crafted in Second age?

[Evisse the Blue]

Can it be worn?
Is it an armour?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it smaller than a door?

[Mithalwen]

Used for offense? No
Is it used to protect a specific individual? Yes
Crafted in Second age? Not that I know of - prob not.
Can it be worn?Yes
Is it an armour? Yes
Is it smaller than a door? Yes

[Firefoot]

The black hauberk worn by the men of the Guard of the Citadel?

[Mithalwen]

The black hauberk worn by the guard of the citadel? No

[NightKnight]

The shield Gimli got from Theoden?

[Evisse the Blue]

Is it mentioned specifically in the story?

[Mithalwen]

The shield Gimli got from Theoden? No
Is it mentioned specifically in the story? - ? Well yes (surely if it weren't I couldn't have chosen it? Confused)

[Celegorm]

The leather hauberk Merry got from Eowyn?

[Firefoot]

Used by a man of Rohan?

[Lindolirian]

The armour of the knights of Dol-Amroth?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it a hauberk?

[Evisse the Blue]

The shield Gimli got from Theoden? No
Is it mentioned specifically in the story? - ? Well yes (surely if it weren't I couldn't have chosen it? Confused)
Sorry about that, I knew I was vague. I meant:
Is its existance implied (for instance, we imagine that Eomer wore a hauberk, but no special mention of it is made...I think....)

[NightKnight]

Is it used by a certain (named) character?

[Mithalwen]

OK I am listing all answers to date since we are occasionally repeating ourselves :)

1, Third Age? Yes
2,Living No?
3, Unique No?
4, Object Yes?
5,Proper name No?
6,Artificial structure - errr... no?
7,Built by a dwarf? No
8,A natural object? No
9,Used by a Man? Yes
10,Used by a man of Gondor? Or Rohan? Yes
11, Built/made by elves? No*
12,Used in battle? Yes
13,Used at the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
14, Used at the battle of Helm's Deep? No
15, Is it a weapon? No
16, Built/made by orcs? No
17,Used for defence? Yes
18,Is it a shield? No
19, Made by man? Yes
20, A helmet? No
21, The City Gate of Gondor? Nope
22, Used for offense? No
23, Is it used to protect a specific individual? Yes
24, Crafted in Second age? Not that I know of - prob not.
25, Can it be worn?Yes
26, Is it an armour? Yes
27,Is it smaller than a door? Yes
28,The black hauberk worn by the guard of the citadel? No
29,The shield Gimli got from Theoden? see 18 ..ie no :)
30 The leather hauberk Merry got from Eowyn? see 9&10 so no ...think that was made specifically?
31, Used by a man of Rohan? No
32,The armour of the knights of Dol-Amroth? See 23 so No
33,Is it a hauberk? No
34, oh Evisse, I see.. no .. while I might have chosen an item belonging to an unnamed char if it were mentioned specifically - I would not give an assumed item of a named character... :D
35, Is it used by a certain (named) character? Yes.

[Firefoot]

Used at the Black Gate?

[Mithalwen]

Used at the Black Gate? (Almost certainly) yes

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Was it Prince Imrahil's vambrace?

[Firefoot]

Belonging to Beregond? His armor?

[NightKnight]

Did it belong to Aragorn?

[Mithalwen]

Tuor has it!!! Well done. The burnished vambrace that Imrahil used to prove Eowyn was still alive.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Pre-empting:

First Age?

[Evisse the Blue]

Living?

[Gil-Galad]

Unique?

[NightKnight]

Third Age?

[Firefoot]

Okay, I'm fine now.

:rolleyes: :D

Living?

[Meneltarmacil]

Is it an object?

And the usual: If I dropped it on Nilpaurion Felagund's head, would it cause brain damage of any kind?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

Sorry for the delay:

First Age?
Yes.

Unique?
Ah...Yes.

Third Age?
Nein.

Living?
Well...Nyet.

Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

[Firefoot]

Place?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

[Lindolirian]

An event?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

[Firefoot]

Happen in Valinor?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

[Lindolirian]

Is it a battle?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

[Lindolirian]

Does it involve Men?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

[Firefoot]

Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

[Firefoot]

Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?

[Firefoot]

Did it involve Maedhros?

[Meneltarmacil]

Was there any violence involved?

[NightKnight]

Did it involve Sindar?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

[Firefoot]

Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

[Lindolirian]

Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

[Firefoot]

When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

[Lindolirian]

After Feanor's death?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

[Firefoot]

Did it happen after the ships were burned?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

[Gil-Galad]

Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

[Gil-Galad]

A Secludued meeting? or met with full arms?

[Tuor of Gondolin]

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

?23 A Secluded meeting? No
or met with full arms? Yes, those involved were armed at the time but
armor wasn't used actively at the event.

[NightKnight]

Maedhros turning away from the burning of the ships?