20 Questions on ME

[Meneltarmacil]

Was this person from Gondor?

[Beregond]

Yes, this person was from the realm of Gondor.

[Meneltarmacil]

Male?

[Beregond]

Yes!

(Only one "no" so far..)

[Meneltarmacil]

Did he appear in LOTR?

Am I the only one asking questions now?

[Beregond]

Yes, you're the only person asking about this third age male mortal from Gondor, in the Lord of the Rings.

[Meneltarmacil]

Is this guy from the lineage of the Stewards?

[Beregond]

Nay, you are astray.

[Nerwen]

Did this person live in Minas Tirith?

[Beregond]

No, this third age male mortal character from LotR lived in the land of Gondor, but not in the White City.

[Meneltarmacil]

Was it Imrahil?

[Beregond]

Nay, not Imrahil by half. :)

[Meneltarmacil]

One of those other nobles that showed up with their armies?

[Beregond]

No, not one of them.

[Meneltarmacil]

A ranger of Ithilien, perhaps?

[Beregond]

To that I also say no. :)

[Ilya]

Did this person fight during the Siege?

[Beregond]

No, he didn't.

[Meneltarmacil]

Would this happen to be the King of the Dead, then?

[Beregond]

Nay, this person is living.

[Ilya]

Was this person of military age during the War?

[Beregond]

I...don't know. Kind of doesn't matter (hint hint). Not too young, certainly!

[Beregond]

I refuse to go down in history as the thread-killer! Here's a hint - this person is...secretive.

And...this third age male mortal character from LotR who lived in the land of Gondor, but not in the White City, is NOT Imrahil or any Lord or Ranger. Nor is he dead. He did not quite fight in the Siege of Minas Tirith and was old, but not necessarily past fighting age. If there is one clue you should pay less attention to, it would be "Gondor".

[Samwise]

Aragorn?

[Beregond]

Goodness, I'd forgot this thread was still mine. No, not Aragorn - and to give you a hint - not even close. :)

[Pitchwife]

Wild guess: Ghân-buri-Ghân?

[Beregond]

YES! Yes, yes, indeed yes, it is him! "Wild" guess payed off. :D

[Pitchwife]

Wow!:D

OK, I've got something. Ask away!

[Beregond]

I'm just glad you got it right before I forgot it! :D

The typical lead-off question: are you thinking of a person?

[Pitchwife]

The typical lead-off question: are you thinking of a person?

1. Yes.

[Samwise]

Is the person of the race of Men?:)

[Pitchwife]

Is the person of the race of Men?:)

2. Yes.

[Samwise]

Is the person male?

[Firefoot]

Is it a character in LotR?

[Pitchwife]

3. Male ? - Yes.
4. character in LotR? - No.

[Firefoot]

First Age?

[Beregond]

Of the house of Hador?

[Pitchwife]

5. First Age? - No.
6. House of Hador? - No.

[Beregond]

A king?

[Pitchwife]

7. No king.

[Firefoot]

Is he from Dale?

[Pitchwife]

8. From Dale? - No...

[Beregond]

From the second age?

[Pitchwife]

9. Second Age? - Nope.

[Firefoot]

From Rohan?

[Pitchwife]

10. Not from Rohan either.

[Firefoot]

From Gondor?

[Pitchwife]

11. Not from Gondor. (getting colder...)

[Beregond]

Of the line of Elendil?

[Pitchwife]

Of the line of Elendil?

12. No.

[Firefoot]

Was he alive before Eorl rode out of the North?

[Pitchwife]

Was he alive before Eorl rode out of the North?

13. No.

(By the way, when I said he was not a character in LotR, I should have added that this includes the Appendices.)

[Firefoot]

Is this character in Unfinished Tales?

[Pitchwife]

14. No, he's not in UT. (And thanks for your patience! I spent the last 3 days in bed with the flu and noticed only today that I forgot to log out last time.)

[Firefoot]

No worries! Glad to hear you're feeling better.

In the Hobbit?

[Pitchwife]

Getting much warmer suddenly, Firefoot...

15. In the Hobbit? - Yes!:D

[Firefoot]

Bard the Bowman?

[Pitchwife]

16. Bard the Bowman? - No, the other one...;)

[Firefoot]

What's he called... the Master of Lake Town?

[Beregond]

Ohhhh, when I read "Not in Dale" earlier I ignored Esgaroth. :)

[Pitchwife]

the Master of Lake Town?

Correct, Firefoot! Please take over. (Sorry, Beregond...;))

[Firefoot]

You and me both, Beregond... that's why it took me so long to get back to the Hobbit.

Proceed guessing.

[Isabellkya]

Is it a person?

[Firefoot]

Is it a person? No

[Isabellkya]

Is it a place?



Does someone else have to ask a question before you can ask another one?
If so, ignore this one. xD

[Firefoot]

Nope, this game could go on forever between two people... not that that's any fun. :cool:

Is it a place? No

[Isabellkya]

Is it an object?

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

Is it an idea?

[Firefoot]

Is it an object? Yes
Is it an idea? No

[Isabellkya]

Is it a weapon?

[Firefoot]

Is it a weapon? No

[Isabellkya]

Can it be held?

[Firefoot]

Can it be held? No

[Isabellkya]

Is it man-made?

[Firefoot]

Is it man-made? Yes

[Isabellkya]

Is it made of Stone?

[Firefoot]

Is it made of stone? No

[Eönwë]

Is it made of wood?

[Firefoot]

Is it made of wood? Yes

[Eönwë]

Is it a building?

[Firefoot]

Is it a building? No

[Isabellkya]

Is it used as a mode of transportation?

[Firefoot]

Is it used as a mode of transportation? Yes

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it found in the Silm?

[Firefoot]

Is it found in the Silm? Yes

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Does it have a name?

[Firefoot]

Does it have a name? No

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it the boat used to send Eärendil's crew back to Middle-earth?

[Firefoot]

Good work, Nilp! You're up.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Thanks. :)

Ask away, then.

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

Is it large?

[Isabellkya]

Is it a person?

[Beregond]

Does its name start with a letter between A and L?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.

[Isabellkya]

Is the person male?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.

Is the person male? Yes.

[Firefoot]

Did he live during the Third Age?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.

Did he live during the Third Age? No.

[Pitchwife]

Is he an Elf?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.

Is he an Elf? No.

[Pitchwife]

Maybe a Dwarf?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.

Maybe a Dwarf? No.

[Firefoot]

1st Age?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.

1st Age? No.

[Pitchwife]

Númenorean?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.

Númenorean? Yes

[McCaber]

Did he spell his name in Adûnaic?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes

Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.

[Pitchwife]

Was he of the Line of Elros?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.

Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.

[Pitchwife]

One of the Kings?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.
Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.

One of the Kings? No.

[Pitchwife]

Time to try a name...

Valandil, Lord of Andúnie?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.
Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.
One of the Kings? No.

Valandil, Lord of Andúnie? Nope, sorry.

[Pitchwife]

I just discovered this is still unsolved, so:

Did he live in the first millennium of the Second Age?

[Urwen]

May I go?

[Urwen]

I'll go.Let's see...I thought of something.

[Blind Guardian]

Can I go?

[The Might]

It's been a while so sure, go ahead.

[Blind Guardian]

Does the name begin with Tar-?

[Pitchwife]

BG, it rather looks like Nilp has completely forgotten about this thread, and I haven't seen him on the Downs for quite a while anyway, so I don't think it makes much sense to ask him any more questions about the last riddle. So if you'd like to take over, just think of something/somebody new, and we can start firing our questions at you, OK? (If in doubt how this works, just read the very first post on this thread.)

[Blind Guardian]

Okay. I have something. Start asking!

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it a person?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a person? NO

[Pitchwife]

Can it be held in a hand?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it a place?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES

[Pitchwife]

Is it or was it located in Middle-earth? (meaning east of the Great Sea)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it an artificial construct (city, fortress, house, rtc.)?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES

[Pitchwife]

Did it exist after the First Age?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Was it made by an elf or elves?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Was it made by dwarves?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it
Was it made by dwarfs NO

[Pitchwife]

Is it west of the Anduin?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it north of Caradhras?

[Blind Guardian]

Making me get my map out hm?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it
Was it made by dwarfs NO
Is it west of the Anduin NO-ish
Is it north of Caradhras NO*




*I can't find Caradhras on my map, but it should be between Rivendell and Moria, right?

[Pitchwife]

Is it west of the Anduin NO-ish
NO-ish? Hmmm...
It's not by any chance Osgiliath, is it?

(Caradhras, by the way, is sitting more or less right on top of Moria.)

[Blind Guardian]

Darn you!

Okay your turn. :p

[Pitchwife]

Thanks!:D I suppose that answer of yours was a bit give-away-ish...;)

OK, fire away everybody!

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it alive?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it a Man?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No

[LadyBrooke]

Is it an elf?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it an olvar?

[Blind Guardian]

Is It a dwarf?

[LadyBrooke]

Is it a Maia?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Female?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No

[LadyBrooke]

Is it a Vala?

[Blind Guardian]

Manwë?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it an orc?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No

[Blind Guardian]

Those giant eagle birds? Like the one that saved bilbo and co in The Hobbit? And the one that rescued Fingolfin's body from Angband?

[LadyBrooke]

Is it Tom Bombadil?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it an evil creature/individual?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it in The Hobbit?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p
Is it in The Hobbit? - No

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Did he live in the First Age?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p
Is it in The Hobbit? - No
Did he live in the First Age? - Hmm... interesting question, now I think about it; but to avoid misleading you, let's say "Presumably not".:cool:

[Blind Guardian]

Did he take part in LotR?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he a bird?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p
Is it in The Hobbit? - No
Did he live in the First Age? - Hmm... interesting question, now I think about it; but to avoid misleading you, let's say "Presumably not".:cool:
Did he take part in LotR? - Yes!!!
Is he a bird? - No

[Blind Guardian]

THere's only two yes answers.


Ent?

[satansaloser2005]

Is it Gollum?

[Blind Guardian]

@Sally Would you consider Gollum evil?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he a wose?

[Estanesse]

Did it help the fellowship in any way?

[Pitchwife]

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p
Is it in The Hobbit? - No
Did he live in the First Age? - Actually, scrap what I said above and make that a clear NO. I was just being nasty and allowing for a crazy theory which isn't substantiated by anything in the book. Sorry for any confusion this may have caused.
Did he take part in LotR? - Yes!!!
Is he a bird? - No
Ent? - No
Gollum? - No
Is he a wose? - We've established above that he's not a Man, which would include the Woses (or Drú-edain); therefore obviously No.
Did it help the fellowship in any way? - Yes, I think you could say he was helpful to some of them.

THere's only two yes answers.
Indeed. Makes me wonder when any of you folks last visited a farm, zoo or circus... (Yeah, that was a hint!)

EDIT: x-ed with Estanesse (hi, pleased to meet you!), question & answer added above.

[Estanesse]

Is it Shadowfax?

[Pitchwife]

(This is getting rather too long to repeat all the Q&A every time, I trust you're all able to look 'em up above)

Is it Shadowfax? - No, but getting warmer!

[Blind Guardian]

oliphant

like elephant?

[Estanesse]

Did it pass the dark door?

[Pitchwife]

Oliphaunt? - No
Did it pass the dark door? - I suppose you mean the entrance to the Paths of the Dead? No, it (or he) came nowhere near the place.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he Bill the Pony?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it BIll?

Edit: darn...

Okay then, Fatty Lumpkin!

[Pitchwife]

Is it Bill the Pony? - Sorry, no. But you're getting closer.

[Blind Guardian]

Fatty Lumpkin?

[Pitchwife]

...and we have a winner!

Well done, BG - Fatty Lumpkin it is! Take the thread!

(To clear up the First Age ambivalence up there: considering that Bombadil has been around for a long, long time and we're never told how old Fatty was, I had that madcap idea that Iarwain Ben-adar's mount could perhaps have been some equally enigmatic long-lived beast along the lines of e.g. Huan or Thorondor; but there's really nothing pointing in that direction beyond his connection with ole Bombadillo, and nothing indicating that he was anything but a regular pony. Sorry if anybody was led astray!)

[satansaloser2005]

Derp. I just realized how stupid my guess was. That's what I get for not reading more carefully. *blushes*

[Blind Guardian]

yEah! When he said bill I thought fatty!

Okay let's see! GO!

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Alive?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes

[Estanesse]

Is it a male?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Is it male? Yes

[Estanesse]

Can it talk?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he in LOTR?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Did he live in or visit Beleriand?

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

Was he an elf?

[Estanesse]

Did he die in battle?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Was he one of the bad guys/creatures?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes

[Tuor in Gondolin]

A dragon?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No

[Estanesse]

Was he ever captured?

[Blind Guardian]

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No
Was he ever captured? Yes

[Pitchwife]

Was he captured more than once?

[Blind Guardian]

You know who this is don’t you? :P


Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No
Was he ever captured? Yes
Was he captured more then once? Yes

[Pitchwife]

I think I do. Morgoth?

[Blind Guardian]

I was thinking more like Melkor but what ever! Okay go ahead!

[Pitchwife]

Thanks!:)
Ok, open fire.

[Blind Guardian]

Is it male?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is it a place?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope

[Blind Guardian]

As he ever been is Beleriand?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope

[Blind Guardian]

Was he a Vala?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope

(By the way, I'm going to be away from my computer from tomorrow till Sunday evening, so have a little patience, please; I'll answer any questions asked in my absence when I get back.)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he an elf?

[Blind Guardian]

Maia?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope

[Blind Guardian]

Ilúvatar?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - Good gracious, no!:D

[Blind Guardian]

What? If he's not a Maia, a Vala, or an elf then what else can he be? Oh!

A Man?




Why wouldn't you use Ilúvatar? One of my favorite charactors next to Melkor :D

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No

What? If he's not a Maia, a Vala, or an elf then what else can he be? Oh!
A Man?
Or a Dwarf, or an Orc, or an Ent, or a... indeed any number of things. Remember my last one was a pony?

Why wouldn't you use Ilúvatar? One of my favorite charactors next to Melkor :D
Oh, I could and I would, but the contrast between your guess and the character I'm actually thinking of was just hilarious; you'll understand when you see who it is. I didn't mean that there was anything wrong with your guess as such - sorry if it came across that way.

[Kyranger]

Is it a person under 4 feet tall?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!

And welcome to the Downs, Kyranger! Enjoy your afterlife!

[Blind Guardian]

HoBbit?

welcome to the 'Downs Kyranger!

[Estanesse]

Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is he ever known to have left the Shire?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)
from whom Thief Baggins stole the Preciouss?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.

[Estanesse]

Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.
Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur? - Yep!

[Estanesse]

Did he work often with ponies?

[Pitchwife]

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.
Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur? - Yep!
Did he work often with ponies? - *goes to check* No, it's the other one.:)

[Estanesse]

Ill make a wild guess:D is it Nob?

[Pitchwife]

Yes it is!:D Well done, Estanesse; the thread is yours!

[Estanesse]

Thank you Pitchwife.
Ask away.

[Kyranger]

Is it a person?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it an Elf?

[Estanesse]

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No

[Blind Guardian]

Man?

[Estanesse]

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No

[Kyranger]

A short person?

[Blind Guardian]

Is it evil?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

A vala or maia?

[Estanesse]

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No

[Blind Guardian]

Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?

[Pitchwife]

Was it alive in the Third Age?

[Estanesse]

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No
Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?- no
Was it alive in the Third Age?- yes

[Tuor in Gondolin]

An orc?