- Virtues in Middle-Earth (5 replies)
- Worst Thing to Fight in but best to discuss (from a distance) (13 replies)
- ***spoiler Warning*** (22 replies)
- The Dark Side of Tom Bombadil (14 replies)
- "Weel done, Cutty-sark!" -Mithril, Moria and Valinorean ship-building (8 replies)
- Pirated books (1 replies)
- The One Ring: A Thing of Beauty? (9 replies)
- Elves in modern times (32 replies)
- How Did Gollum Lose the Ring? (9 replies)
- Newbie help please (14 replies)
- Oath of Feanor (6 replies)
- Please help. (5 replies)
- Where did Hobbits come from? (38 replies)
- Big Mystery: The Nine Rings of Power (19 replies)
- Did JRRT encourage new ME stories? (323 replies)
- History Of Middle Earth (1 replies)
- Aragorn in Moria? (19 replies)
- Splendid but Unhappy (13 replies)
- **Official B D B D Newspaper Annoucement!** (0 replies)
- Quotes/References in the Children of Hurin (6 replies)
- Turin the Hopeless? (102 replies)
- Seven: Four From Five or One? (17 replies)
- Watch this Clip NOW (22 replies)
- Sign of the Shadow (4 replies)
- Does it count as survival? (21 replies)
- Lord Melkor Rightful Master of the Fates of Arda (127 replies)
- What language did the Firbeards and Broadbeams for there names? (2 replies)
- Verlyn Flieger (11 replies)
- More than meets the Eye (15 replies)
- Black Book of Arda (3 replies)
- Morgul Blades (2 replies)
- A word by any other name ... (25 replies)
- The Wizards of Middle-Earth... (6 replies)
- Damned if you do, kablammed if you don't (11 replies)
- What happens if... (16 replies)
- Mordor makes me thirsty! The power of Tolkien! (24 replies)
- Medemocracy (10 replies)
- 'Run off into the Blue' (11 replies)
- Did Gollum deserve death? (217 replies)
- A 'darker' Hobbit (85 replies)
- Time in Middle-earth (23 replies)
- How many people touched the One Ring ? (15 replies)
- LoTR version with new index (3 replies)
- soldiers available in ME (18 replies)
- Finarfin is a Nandor (1 replies)
- Shock! Horror! Feanor does what a Vala says... (6 replies)
- History of Middle-earth Index (4 replies)
- Words and Names in Tolkien's Work (27 replies)
- Who were the Nazgul? (25 replies)
- Aliens? (10 replies)
- Sauron vs. Your Mama - A Discussion of Power in Middle-earth (98 replies)
- Hobbit age? (6 replies)
- Fair Fight (20 replies)
- Sam and the Ring (17 replies)
- Map of Arda... (4 replies)
- Why is northern Eriador (Lake Evendim, Fornost) deserted at the end of the 3rd Age? (25 replies)
- Character Charisma (2 replies)
- The Wild Men (5 replies)
- On Numernorean Appearance (3 replies)
- Legolas and Gimli...fiddling around the City? (5 replies)
- Professional Treasure-seekers? (11 replies)
- What if Bilbo (or Frodo) had TRIED to use the full power of the Ring? (6 replies)
- Enemies (109 replies)
- Barad-dur (12 replies)
- It's the end of an era (but how did they know?) (4 replies)
- A Query On Lothlorien (15 replies)
- Dwarf women debate solved? (5 replies)
- Inconsistencies in the book (17 replies)
- Who was in the Host of the 'Valar'? (7 replies)
- Morgoth's curse (2 replies)
- Beards (8 replies)
- Wolfram von Tolkienbach (6 replies)
- Flaws in the Middle Earth map (8 replies)
- Favourite Part of Unfinished Tales? (39 replies)
- 'He called her by her Elvish name' (1 replies)
- As the Balrog flies (10 replies)
- The White Council assaults Dol Guldur? (43 replies)
- Details on the Inscription of the Western Gate of Moria (4 replies)
- The Great Eye In Dol Guldur? (11 replies)
- Where did all the goblins go? (34 replies)
- Breaking of the World (16 replies)
- In this House of Elrond..... (6 replies)
- Common cold beyond the Ring? (8 replies)
- Treebeard's fate (8 replies)
- How many Huorns ? (3 replies)
- The most lied about book.... (42 replies)
- Sauron the Unnamed... really? (9 replies)
- Elf Rights Watch needed? Yet again a new Míriel thread! (10 replies)
- Melkor is the saviour of mankind (26 replies)
- What did they think? (20 replies)
- Lord of the Rings and Philosophy @ Concordia University Wisconsin (39 replies)
- "Cruel deeds by dark and light" (5 replies)
- Isildur's Bane (7 replies)
- Sister (10 replies)
- East of the Barrow (1 replies)
- Who were the men refusing the call of Gondor? (14 replies)
- I think this needs clEaring up (1 replies)
- Why did Gandalf save Faramir? (39 replies)
- What event? (1 replies)
- Wargs from the past? (1 replies)
- Lost Tale of a Lost Dwarven Tribe and Thranduil? (15 replies)
- Tolkien's music (6 replies)
- You really got a hold on me (13 replies)
- Great lotr music (2 replies)
- The atrocity of the Akallabęth (312 replies)
- The Elves - What have they ever done for us? (19 replies)
- Riders Of Rohan - Anglo Saxons? (18 replies)
- Blame lembas? (4 replies)
- Ship of the Dark (8 replies)
- RE: Elrond/ next high king of the Noldor. (9 replies)
- Matriarchal or Patriarchal societies in ME ??? (27 replies)
- Why Did the Nazgul Wait at Crickhollow? (10 replies)
- Hobbits in Valinor? (20 replies)
- Did Saruman actually get a second chance (3 replies)
- The three rings of power that the elve had (10 replies)
- Maybe it's just nonsense but... (11 replies)
- Fire of Isengard ? (4 replies)
- No other way ? (11 replies)
- RE: the Towers. (11 replies)
- “I am da Law” (19 replies)
- Mouth of Sauron at Erebor ? (13 replies)
- A Christmas Thread (6 replies)
- The Iron Hills, the most powerful kingdom in Wilderland? (3 replies)
- question regarding sentinels (2 replies)
- Where the heck is Belegost (6 replies)
- What's this?! (29 replies)
- It's 1984 in the Third Age (26 replies)
- Shell-shocked Frodo .... or .... PTSD in LOTR (23 replies)
- Tolkien's 'Deus ex Machina' (16 replies)
- Surprising Literary Congruences (8 replies)
- The Influence of William Morris (6 replies)
- Dwarves still in the Ered Mithrin? (13 replies)
- The Voice of Saruman / The Voice of Hitler (7 replies)
- when did you read lotr for the first time? (12 replies)
- LOTR - classist? (38 replies)
- How could the Nazgul take Minas Morgul? (69 replies)
- Could Gandalf have won the war alone? (17 replies)
- Buckland (3 replies)
- Where is Breredon please ? (11 replies)
- Failure and Punishment (68 replies)
- Farmer Giles of Ham - obviously Catholic? (20 replies)
- What did Tolkien really mean .... (26 replies)
- Elven Children (17 replies)
- One of these things is not like the others... (15 replies)
- About Saruman and the Shire (9 replies)
- Why take a body? Why make a Ring? (51 replies)
- How would you have gone about more successfully toppling Sauron ? (13 replies)
- Beorn (38 replies)
- Financial Legacy (0 replies)
- 7th Age RPG Invitation (0 replies)
- Tolkien lied! (13 replies)
- The treachery of the Valar (10 replies)
- Were the Istari Unable or Unwilling... (14 replies)
- Did Saruman Believe He Could Master The One Ring? (76 replies)
- Arcane Topic Warning: Part the Fifth (19 replies)
- Book Debates: Quoting from Other Sources (0 replies)
- Melkor/Arda Marred or Remade (10 replies)
- The Lord of the Rings and the Fall-Winter Seasons (16 replies)
- Demons from the Ancient World (29 replies)
- Parallels between Gandalf and Glorfindel (9 replies)
- First appearance/mention of Gandalf (5 replies)
- Sorcery (39 replies)
- CT's lawyer lays the facts down (19 replies)
- Boundaries of Wilderland (1 replies)
- Fords of Isen Battles Puzzles (2 replies)
- Please contact me (3 replies)
- Tolkien's 'Smith of Wootton Major' & George MacDonald's 'Phantastes': A Comparison (22 replies)
- Elladan and Elrohir (7 replies)
- Saruman and betrayal (45 replies)
- The Inklings' Challenge (6 replies)
- "Genuine fairy-story" ? (42 replies)
- What Were Their Purposes? (3 replies)
- What was it all for? (41 replies)
- The Undying Lands (14 replies)
- Christopher Tolkien to finish lost Middle Earth novel (441 replies)
- Sauron Vs the Ring (19 replies)
- New Tolkien Book (3 replies)
- Other magic Rings? (12 replies)
- Translations from the English (6 replies)
- Do ents lay eggs? (19 replies)
- The Istari (2 replies)
- The Forsaken Inn (13 replies)
- Where did Gandalf live? (28 replies)
- Tolkien's Literary Executor (13 replies)
- Gondor, Rohan and Lorien (25 replies)
- Am I missing something? (5 replies)
- The Conversation and Ties between Gandalf and Tom Bombadil (4 replies)
- Rhosgobel? (2 replies)
- The Hedge (7 replies)
- The Nightmare World of Tolkien (42 replies)
- Arcane Topic Warning: Part the Fourth (5 replies)
- Why did the Nazgul not succeed in Bree and on Weathertop? (42 replies)
- Sorry...Have to ask about historical analogy... (5 replies)
- Sauron and Gollum (10 replies)
- An easy way to destroy the Ring . (1 replies)
- Reason Behind The Decline Of Arnor And The Rise Of Gondor. (14 replies)
- "la voce di edoras"(Tolkien,Fantasy,RPG&MMORPG) (1 replies)
- Back to my basic reading roots. (6 replies)
- Quotes Galore (2 replies)
- gandalf and the name incanus (23 replies)
- Legolas (9 replies)
- Eomer and Eowyn's Gondorian Kin (3 replies)
- Thuringwethil (33 replies)
- The Lord of the Bible? (467 replies)
- An interview with J.R.R. Tolkien (2 replies)
- More! More! More! (23 replies)
- Temptation of Boromir (15 replies)
- 'The Breath of Life'/ The Black Breath (3 replies)
- Saruman's REAL name (4 replies)
- Arwen's Mortality (24 replies)
- The Voice of Saruman (15 replies)
- How to escape the Nazgűl (8 replies)
- "for it was always there." (9 replies)
- King of the Dead vs Witch King (26 replies)
- Faery and Flow - the Passage of Time (3 replies)
- Can Sauron still live (5 replies)
- Why save them? (39 replies)
- Real and Fake History: Can it be the Same? (17 replies)
- Tolkien's shifting style (11 replies)
- Concerning Legolas (9 replies)
- Arcane Topic Warning: Part the Third (68 replies)
- Comical Parts (19 replies)
- 'Spun Candy' anyone? (160 replies)
- Sam and The Moon (7 replies)
- family names (0 replies)
- Elves socioeconomic system. (25 replies)
- Life or Honor? (20 replies)
- The Numenorean Might Dilemma (2 replies)
- My Essay: "A Defense of Character: Boromir" (8 replies)
- Unpublished Tolkien Letter for sale! (14 replies)
- The ring could have been destroyed a lot easier. (25 replies)
- Arcane Topic Warning: Part the Second (46 replies)
- Galadriel VS The witch- king (43 replies)
- Has it all been said? (42 replies)
- True Hero: Frodo or Samwise? (38 replies)
- Parallels in LotR (10 replies)
- Matter of choice (10 replies)
- Heighty is mighty? (41 replies)
- Gothmog (7 replies)
- Why did Gandalf have a ring? (20 replies)
- Eldest? (37 replies)
- Ages and Stages (0 replies)
- The Prophecy of Durin VII (3 replies)
- The obscure regions (5 replies)
- 21st Century Tolkien (34 replies)
- Orcs... were elves? (63 replies)
- Saruman the Good (22 replies)
- The downfall of the hobbit-folk (26 replies)
- The Westward Road (26 replies)
- I get knocked down but I get up again - you're never going to keep me down. (32 replies)