- Childe Rowland elements in the Barrow-downs tale (0 replies)
- Mortal stowaway on elven ships (6 replies)
- The Green Light in the Barrow and the god Lugh (0 replies)
- Bombadil & little old men in fairy tales (0 replies)
- Bombadil’s Green Girdle (14 replies)
- Orc intergration after the War? (17 replies)
- The Hobbit Trolls - A Clever Parody? (14 replies)
- Strider Said This Strider Did That (6 replies)
- Tom Bombadil & Jack of Beanstalk Fame (2 replies)
- Why did Aragorn not tell the Fellowship Gollum was following them? (1 replies)
- Why didn't Morgulduin pollute the lower Anduin? (1 replies)
- How did Gollum get out of Moria? (16 replies)
- Thrain in Dol Guldur (10 replies)
- Saruman's Pits (20 replies)
- Who on middle-earth is Lotho? (10 replies)
- Interesting article about Variags (29 replies)
- Tom Bombadil & Color Symbolism – A New Approach (1 replies)
- Elementals (13 replies)
- Sauron's Great Miscalculation (42 replies)
- So he is responsible....... (9 replies)
- Goldberry: A plausible reason behind her many faces? (0 replies)
- An interesting snippet (11 replies)
- Goldberry, Arthur Rackham & Undine (0 replies)
- michio kaku and the ainulindale: discuss (or Eru rejoices in mankind Seeing (2 replies)
- Transmission theory: what the heck was Tolkien thinking? (24 replies)
- Utopian Intersections in the works of J.R.R. Tolkien (10 replies)
- Christopher Tolkien awarded the Bodley Medal (0 replies)
- Gandalf....fortune teller?? (8 replies)
- Beren and Lùthien to be published as stand alone volume (36 replies)
- Goldberry: A new reading on the origin of her name (5 replies)
- Facsimile of first edition of 'The Hobbit' (3 replies)
- Smaug Is Not a Bookworm (14 replies)
- Third Dark Lord, or Melkor's Return? (13 replies)
- Sauron the Gene-maker (19 replies)
- Languages Smaug spoke? (17 replies)
- The Worlds of Miyazaki Hayao and JRR Tolkien (0 replies)
- The New Shadow - Your thoughts? (18 replies)
- Aragorn's assertiveness (40 replies)
- Tolkien's political views (27 replies)
- The "Well what next?" fox and The One Ring (11 replies)
- The Morgoth-element. (8 replies)
- Treebeard and the One Ring (10 replies)
- Balrog and The One Ring (37 replies)
- The Metaphysics and Ontology of Ëa, Arda, and Middle-earth (6 replies)
- Favourite minor character? (25 replies)
- Authorial Control and World Building (18 replies)
- Eldarin kingship and succession (31 replies)
- 'Return of the Ring' proceedings now available (0 replies)
- Faramir's descendants (2 replies)
- What Powered The Three? (28 replies)
- Prince Imrahil and his mortality (26 replies)
- Where do elves get metal? (93 replies)
- Concerning Mewlips (2 replies)
- Tolkien's Numerical Fixation (5 replies)
- Two poems by Tolkien found in 1936 school magazine (0 replies)
- Chicken and egg, Ent and tree... (3 replies)
- The forest of Helm's Deep (3 replies)
- The Fellowship - doomed to fail (46 replies)
- Using Tolkien to Score Some Points (12 replies)
- Demonyms (3 replies)
- The strange paths of Elvish dreams (2 replies)
- There and Back Again (33 replies)
- For Jim Allan (0 replies)
- The Half-Elven Foundation-VII (10 replies)
- The foundation and transformation of Sméagol's character and the role of the Ring (4 replies)
- The Timeline of LotR and the Church Calendar (3 replies)
- The Interactions of the Ring-Bearers (22 replies)
- Beorn(Arda Annual) (7 replies)
- "Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages" (47 replies)
- The doom of the Ring (10 replies)
- Two Tolkien related books on Project Gutenberg website (2 replies)
- Who are the 'wild men'? (48 replies)
- Tom Bombadil – An Intriguing Answer ! (78 replies)
- Exciting Tolkien find - map lovers alert.. (14 replies)
- Was Glorfindel's horse one of the Mearas? (12 replies)
- Fatty Bolger (8 replies)
- Otherworldly light in Lothlorien (3 replies)
- How do you perceive Tom Bombadil? (55 replies)
- Were Dragons inherently "evil"? (24 replies)
- The dissolving Morgul blade (9 replies)
- A Tolkien lecture from Carnegie Mellon (1 replies)
- Curse of Túrin (32 replies)
- The Hobbit Play - Authorized by Tolkien (5 replies)
- For all who study tolkien's languages! (14 replies)
- Obscure Tolkien Characters (30 replies)
- Looking For Quotes About Morgoth (8 replies)
- The Shadow of the Maker (12 replies)
- Tolkien's Floral Fixation (21 replies)
- The Story of Kullervo (12 replies)
- Fantasy Counterpart Culture (20 replies)
- Did Frodo REALLY volunteer to Bear the Ring? (58 replies)
- Obscure Topics of the Legendarium (45 replies)
- Gandalf’s Possible Inaccuracy in the chapter “The Shadow of the Past” (50 replies)
- The effect of the Great Rings upon Men (102 replies)
- The Longetivity of Hobbits. (18 replies)
- Heaven and the ocean (12 replies)
- The Addictive Ring (18 replies)
- Why do you read HoME? (30 replies)
- Scholarly Edition of The Adventures of Tom Bombadil (9 replies)
- Isengard- Help Wanted! (19 replies)
- Tom Bombadil: Evil? (4 replies)
- Who was older - Treebeard or Bombadil (3 replies)
- New words about Bombadil (12 replies)
- Boats travelling up and down Anduin and Lorien's isolation. (12 replies)
- Food supplies for elves (16 replies)
- Tolkien's Secret Hidden Code (12 replies)
- Question for the Sindarin experts: is Meril still valid? (44 replies)
- Surely Elrond would have insisted on Merry and Pippin NOT going? (4 replies)
- Surely the Fellowship took the wrong route? (4 replies)
- Who is on the cover of the Silmarillion (13 replies)
- Sauron, Morgoth and the lust for beauty (4 replies)
- Was Gandalf wrong? (3 replies)
- Mayoral elections at Michel Delving (4 replies)
- Gnomes and Fairies (21 replies)
- Theoden's sisters' sons? (13 replies)
- The Book of Lost Tales Part I: A Readthrough (89 replies)
- The Essence of the Tale (10 replies)
- "That is the Way for Us" - But Which Way? (7 replies)
- Ori's writing (16 replies)
- What role did greed play in Tolkien's books? (23 replies)
- As A Villain - Morgoth or Sauron? (1 replies)
- Why Frodo is so misunderstood and underrated character? (14 replies)
- Was the Balrog drawn by the ring? (43 replies)
- Individual sacrifices at the end of each age (6 replies)
- Talking animals. (9 replies)
- Middle-earth What-ifs (67 replies)
- An early Lord of the Rings fan review (8 replies)
- Ancalagon the Black (21 replies)
- What if Gandalf the White killed the Witch King? (18 replies)
- Tolkien's Beowulf (1 replies)
- Tolkien and the origin of Treebeard (1 replies)
- Durin's Axe (4 replies)
- Tolkien and World War I (2 replies)
- What if Gollum had lived? (36 replies)
- Sentient Animals in LOTR and Silmarillion (7 replies)
- Unusual question? (30 replies)
- How Saruon could have won the Dwaves to his side; my crackpot theory (1 replies)
- Why not Sam as an 'Elf-friend'? (5 replies)
- What would they do? (11 replies)
- Arnorian successor states? 3 or more (12 replies)
- what if....... (1 replies)
- What Would You Do As Boromir? (4 replies)
- Fingolfin's Death - Suicide? (11 replies)
- ME Warriors (2 replies)
- Sauron Wins...Then What? (47 replies)
- longbottom (3 replies)
- Hobbits (2 replies)
- Saruman Questions (1 replies)
- The Great Evils of the Third Age (4 replies)
- Why not Ecthelion? (36 replies)
- The Original Plan for the Fellowship? (12 replies)
- Hi, i have problem (1 replies)
- New Unicode runes Tolkien (3 replies)
- The Unfair Fate of Saruman (25 replies)
- Gollum's sacrifice (12 replies)
- Gollum's sacrifice (0 replies)
- who are the nazgul? (22 replies)
- Are Elves vegatarian? (82 replies)
- Tolkien was the Offspring of Eru's Thought! A Thought Experiment (2 replies)
- how durin founded the longbeards (27 replies)
- Of Orcs and Elves - Mirror Image Opposites or Not? (10 replies)
- why sauron cant breed werewolves/dragons? (13 replies)
- Arnor- Designed For Failure? (31 replies)
- army styles of the kingdoms in middle earth (5 replies)
- could the easterling breach erebor? (8 replies)
- Why did Aragorn not tell the Company that Gollum was folling them? (1 replies)
- what happen if numenor didnt rebel against the valar? (18 replies)
- Free Will in Tolkien's World (2 replies)
- could any of the kingdoms at middle earth attack the southern continents? (45 replies)
- what would possibly exist in the farthest east? (30 replies)
- Defending Rohan during the battle of the Pennor Fields (8 replies)
- Why didn't Morgulduin pollute the lower Anduin? (5 replies)
- Do Elves lack Civil Courgae? (6 replies)
- Prince of Dol Amroth the descandant of Mithrellas or kin of Elendil? (0 replies)
- The dilution of Elven blood and subsequent mortality (7 replies)
- Gimli's forgetfulness? (11 replies)
- Tolkien's Beowulf to be published! (17 replies)
- Mauhur and his lads (6 replies)
- Manning the Rammas Echor (6 replies)
- Gondor: dealings with Elves (5 replies)
- Would Saruman have been a reliable ally? (16 replies)
- Why didn't Galadriel warn Aragorn that Boromir wanted the Ring? (18 replies)
- How did Gildor's messages get to Aragorn and Rivendell so fast? (10 replies)
- From Tom Bombadil's house to the Road (6 replies)
- How to Locate the Lost Palantiri in the Reunited Kingdom (8 replies)
- How to Make a Ringwraith versus Extending the Elven Body--an Elven Ring (7 replies)
- What became of Ted Sandyman? (6 replies)
- Orcs and healing (18 replies)
- Your Take On Eöl & Maeglin (17 replies)
- The LOTR Audibooks read by Rob Inglis (1 replies)
- Why did Sauron fear Aragons coronation? (13 replies)
- Why didn't Saruman kill the Ents himself? (12 replies)
- Elven Characteristics (65 replies)
- Eregion in Other Languages (3 replies)
- the original Foreword (4 replies)
- What are Tolkien's lasting writings? (5 replies)
- house of hurin of emyn arnen revisited (7 replies)
- What if Glorfindel joined the fellowship to Lothlorien? (43 replies)
- Boromir - An example of a man? (23 replies)
- Yet Another Magic/Subcreativity thread (1 replies)
- The Inherent Incompatability of Morgoth and Sauron (35 replies)
- Bilbo´s treachery (159 replies)
- Sauron's name (24 replies)
- Orcs on both sides (10 replies)
- Elves and the Elements (8 replies)
- Gandalf vs. Sauron (Hobbit Movie Spoilers) (5 replies)
- What differentiates the Valar from the Maiar? (11 replies)
- More than five Istari? (3 replies)
- Mightiest of the Maiar? (13 replies)
- Poundage of Legolas' bow (0 replies)
- Gandalf and the council of White Wizards (2 replies)
- Thorin's Heir (19 replies)
- Thorin and the Dwarves once coal diggers? (10 replies)
- Saurons Weapon of Choice? (57 replies)
- Hammond & Scull's Cautionary Tale of Tolkien Studies (2 replies)
- Maladies of Maleficence (8 replies)
- Gollum questions. (26 replies)
- Why was Boromir allowed to join the Fellowship? (35 replies)
- What did Sam see in the Mirrormere/Kheled-zaram ? (3 replies)
- Is The Children of Hurin better than the Lord of the Rings? (33 replies)
- Sauron's nature (2 replies)
- Can Hobbits and Men learn Elf/Dwarf art and craft? (11 replies)
- Tolkien the Metafictionist (51 replies)
- Sauron and Istari (30 replies)
- Why did Aule want to destroy Dwarves (11 replies)
- How close is the published The Silmarillion to JRRT's Silmarillion? (54 replies)
- The Nature of the Nine (6 replies)
- Saruman (5 replies)
- Why didn't Grima.... (3 replies)
- How to simplify the Lord of the Rings and Silmarillion? (11 replies)
- Gandalf the Grey and Gandalf the White (2 replies)
- Were the Istari already old men...? (11 replies)
- The random ‘Questions about Tolkien’s early poetry and Unpublished Writing' thread (3 replies)
- "A shadow and a thought" interpretation? (14 replies)
- Elrond's speech (9 replies)
- The Dangers of Arnor (2 replies)
- What do you fight for? (6 replies)
- The Seven and the Nine (5 replies)
- The Fates of Elros' and Elronds' Heirs (11 replies)
- Ronald and Sprague (3 replies)
- Sauron's Super Army? (27 replies)
- Westron translations? (12 replies)
- The Nine and the Three (1 replies)
- I Hate Feanor (30 replies)
- Did Tolkien even plan to fill in the other sections of Middle-earth? (4 replies)
- Saving Gollum (6 replies)
- Saruman's Words to Gandalf and Galadriel (13 replies)
- Gollum and Pleasure (18 replies)
- Resurrection of Numenor and Tar-Miriel (3 replies)
- Could Eru change the very laws of nature if he wanted to? (16 replies)