View Full Version : The Books
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
[
7]
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
- Well, Gandalf, it's nice to see you again, but... (26 replies)
- The Fëanor inside Fëanor Sons (18 replies)
- **ANNOUNCEMENT - BARROW-DOWNS BIRTHDAY MAY 1st!** (4 replies)
- Outsourcing canon (6 replies)
- Lord of the Rings - English Icon (23 replies)
- Three vs. One (5 replies)
- Edain who remained in Middle-Earth (6 replies)
- Tolkien's Funny Bone (37 replies)
- Regarding the Enemy (18 replies)
- When was Gandalf in Moria? (12 replies)
- Yeah, but ... it's fake (15 replies)
- Absolutely Evil (53 replies)
- Anatomy of an Ent (11 replies)
- Of another world (237 replies)
- Drama out of nothing... perhaps (Regarding the War of the Ring) (19 replies)
- What New Evils Was Sauron Forging? (11 replies)
- Faramir's (and Boromir's) Dream (54 replies)
- The Recapture of north-east Beleriand (11 replies)
- Gandalf/Eagle -> Ring -> Mt. Doom? (3 replies)
- Middle-earth Mysteries (55 replies)
- "Lord of the Rings" sequel! (18 replies)
- An Unlikely Theory: Blue Wizards as Tom and Golberry (5 replies)
- Bombadil in the Last Alliance? (4 replies)
- Bombadil vs. Sauron? (10 replies)
- Gil-Galad's Tragedy (7 replies)
- If there was a writer capable... (17 replies)
- Downfall of Númenor -> Culpable are the Valar? (7 replies)
- Dwarves of the East and West (2 replies)
- Orcseys - always Evil? (66 replies)
- Relative Powers (217 replies)
- Northern Line vs. Southern Line (10 replies)
- Thorin's Halls (6 replies)
- Read LotR before you die! (16 replies)
- LotR, an Edwardian Adventure Story? (38 replies)
- Valinor and Frodo (5 replies)
- Glorfindel? (4 replies)
- Alternate "Hiding the Ring" strategies (51 replies)
- Il Principe (of Beleriand...) (27 replies)
- Contents of Mallorn, Mythlore and Beyond Bree journals (7 replies)
- The Arkenstone (17 replies)
- Dragon-Fire (16 replies)
- Creations of Melkor (3 replies)
- Gollum and Eagles: Deux ex machina? (85 replies)
- Varda&Melkor and Marriages of Valar (10 replies)
- The Breaking of the Hogwarts Fellowship (19 replies)
- Elrond Peradan (13 replies)
- Power to the People (37 replies)
- Silmarillion: Main characters (Book report) (39 replies)
- Who's King Now? (3 replies)
- Modes of Interpretation?? (1 replies)
- 'Which is as Fate to all Things Else’ (43 replies)
- Tolkien was human right? (12 replies)
- money in middle earth (30 replies)
- Don't do me like that (126 replies)
- Maiar or Man? (6 replies)
- Ballantine Cover Font? (8 replies)
- Elentári (2 replies)
- England's Mythology? (33 replies)
- Stick to your territory, AN Wilson! (2 replies)
- What would Tolkien say? (7 replies)
- Generals and armies (10 replies)
- The Decision to Croak. (14 replies)
- How can hope and despair be akin? (27 replies)
- Radagast the Green? (11 replies)
- Tolkien's Beowulf (12 replies)
- Lore & Learning in Middle-earth (5 replies)
- Some History and a Question..... (18 replies)
- I Found the Entwives! (152 replies)
- A Happy Ending... or is it? (29 replies)
- What does the sixpence = ? (63 replies)
- Questions on Adunaic and Quenya (8 replies)
- Why'd Sharkey do that? (13 replies)
- Character by Character? (7 replies)
- Gandalf blew Galadriel's cover?! (16 replies)
- Middle Earth "afterlife" (26 replies)
- Khand-Moria-Carn dum coincidence (13 replies)
- Are Ents free? (7 replies)
- Sauron and collectivism (14 replies)
- Hobbits as soldiers? (16 replies)
- Tolkien over others (18 replies)
- Melkor (7 replies)
- Who or What is Tom Bombadil? (70 replies)
- Who delivered the final blow? (36 replies)
- Galadriel's death (8 replies)
- "Critters of Moria" (12 replies)
- Gnomes (3 replies)
- What's the Worst Thing Characters had to Face in Middle Earth? (43 replies)
- Tolkien and Norse Mythology (74 replies)
- Is Eru God? (262 replies)
- Would he have done it? (21 replies)
- Calling all women (82 replies)
- decent of house of hurin (10 replies)
- The Nandor-Lenwe's people? (1 replies)
- Was it legit? (16 replies)
- If Gollum and Bilbo had parted in a civil manner... (15 replies)
- The mouth of Sauron (8 replies)
- WWII and LOTR..Compare/Contrast (17 replies)
- Spiders? (40 replies)
- Tolkien and the 'other' N-word ;) (30 replies)
- Ent-wives slaves (28 replies)
- To be complete... (3 replies)
- What happened at Mount Doom? (50 replies)
- Aragorn's Reunited Empire: Just a paper dream? (29 replies)
- Tolkien and Asimov (20 replies)
- Witch King (12 replies)
- Giants and Ogres? (8 replies)
- Authorial Detachment or "The Vanishing Harper" (13 replies)
- Quick Question(s) (3 replies)
- Tolkien and the Book (20 replies)
- Are elves stupid ? (10 replies)
- Curses! (20 replies)
- You say 'Faeries' & I say 'Fairies' (96 replies)
- Unorthodox Heroes? (38 replies)
- Compliment... or not? (13 replies)
- CbC: Silm or TH? (39 replies)
- Belling the Ring (41 replies)
- For the Love of Galadriel (Middle-earth’s Ultimate Muse?) (25 replies)
- Ulmo and Aulë: Lazy, Busy, or Unaware (13 replies)
- Is it so important... (1 replies)
- Galadriel & Melian (2 replies)
- The Root of all Evil. (26 replies)
- Hobbits and shoes (15 replies)
- The bearers of the Three (6 replies)
- “Not all those who wander are lost.” (40 replies)
- Ilúvatar's other theme. (12 replies)
- Who would have fallen? (112 replies)
- Melkor's depiction by artists: Flawed? (33 replies)
- Why Bilbo? (12 replies)
- By george dwarves are british, i think (15 replies)
- Adoption and Foster Care (27 replies)
- How much did the Hobbits really abhor adventure? (1 replies)
- 3 + 9, x (7+12) Divided by Eleventy-one... oh dear (33 replies)
- The 14th History of Middle Earth Book? (8 replies)
- Dwarves and Mordor (19 replies)
- Galadhremmin Ennorath (16 replies)
- M-m-meaning! Let's define, is it 'meaning' or 'Meaning', or if there's any at all... (37 replies)
- Canon: what ARE we babbling about? (107 replies)
- Does LotR have cross-cultural appeal? (46 replies)
- The Grace of Ilúvatar? (27 replies)
- Why Moria? (77 replies)
- How Would it Be? (12 replies)
- Gothmog: the poll (43 replies)
- Misc. Questions (83 replies)
- When they die, where do they go? (10 replies)
- The love of Eärendil (6 replies)
- Arwen's Love for Aragorn (8 replies)
- Spirits in jewellery (7 replies)
- Saruman for or against Sauron? (96 replies)
- Why the Lord of the Rings? (8 replies)
- The True Master. (50 replies)
- The Point of the Unions (16 replies)
- Shadows of former glory (7 replies)
- Arcane Topic Warning! Probably only Dwarf fans will find this interesting. (9 replies)
- The Ring bearer (11 replies)
- Need info on J.R.R. Tolkien Audio Collection (6 replies)
- Rocks, Hard Places, etc.... (74 replies)
- Elendil's Sword and Sauron's Ring (39 replies)
- Is this all there is? (15 replies)
- The Treason of Isengard: Eru's Plan? (70 replies)
- Author, Reader, or Text? (aka Canonicity Slapdown 2005) (92 replies)
- The Ring of Saruman? (78 replies)
- three rings for the elven-kings under the sky (3 replies)
- Tolkien-founder of new religion? (50 replies)
- Why Tom's songs (5 replies)
- A Latent Desire? (15 replies)
- itsy bitsy doubts (8 replies)
- Mellyrn don't sing, do they? (5 replies)
- Isildur (10 replies)
- Everyone trusts in Eru? (14 replies)
- The Extent of Applicability (1 replies)
- Earendil a Man? Or Aragorn as King of Arnor? (5 replies)
- Luthien & Galadriel (60 replies)
- And it slips through our fingers (61 replies)
- Why Entwives? (20 replies)
- Ainur marriages and what comes after (7 replies)
- King Elessar's Folly? (11 replies)
- That good night: gift or punishment? (56 replies)
- Genetic engineering, the Golden Wood and Gandalf (6 replies)
- Outrage? (219 replies)
- Eminence Grise-or "Grey is the new White" (9 replies)
- Denethor's dislike of Gandalf (15 replies)
- Maps in Sil andLOTR (2 replies)
- Elven Princes- What power do they have (3 replies)
- Gandalf: the Unilateral Coalition Builder (23 replies)
- The Entwives (17 replies)
- Hurin the Wraith (12 replies)
- Pippin's Song (11 replies)
- Just wanted to point out... [Eowyn changes] (24 replies)
- Did Maedhros fight in the War of Wrath? (3 replies)
- If Frodo had thrown the Ring in right away (12 replies)
- The Translator Conceit (49 replies)
- Poll - (S)pacing the CbC discussions (16 replies)
- Gandalf a "steward?" (74 replies)
- Missing Moirae? (3 replies)
- What breaks the enchantment? (169 replies)
- Who was the most foolish ruler of all? (31 replies)
- The Single Greatest (Publishing) Tragedy in Tolkien's Life (yet another rant) (26 replies)
- more than 9? (29 replies)
- Tolkien--Inspirations and Inspired (3 replies)
- Who does Galadriel resemble? (8 replies)
- The Zoom-In (4 replies)
- The Difference of the Species (12 replies)
- The Nature of Magic in Middle-Earth (5 replies)
- Invitation to the Barrow Birthday Party (0 replies)
- A Most Unusual Dwarf (27 replies)
- Be LotR be an allegory fer fightin' Communism? (14 replies)
- What power is Elrond referring to? (27 replies)
- Should I read....? (6 replies)
- Question on Brandir. (2 replies)
- Farmer Giles, Thane of Glamis (1 replies)
- The ultimate fate of the half elves between Beren/Luthian and Earindel/Elwing (5 replies)
- Interview with Humphrey Carpenter (0 replies)
- The Doom of Eucatastrophe (8 replies)
- Bard & The Master Vs Aragorn & the House of Stewards (14 replies)
- Smith of Wootton Major in Middle Earth? (77 replies)
- The Men of Dale (6 replies)
- Saruman's economic infrastructure unexplained? (37 replies)
- Tactical Discussion-Warg Charge (27 replies)
- Feanor's Wrath (43 replies)
- Tolkien, the Artist (36 replies)
- Reincarnation (13 replies)
- The Emblems of Religion don't belong ... or do they? (88 replies)
- Favorite Chapter of Lord of the Rings (15 replies)
- Tolkien and mythologies (3 replies)
- Sauron Diminished? (13 replies)
- Textile Arts and Tolkien (6 replies)
- Galadriel's intentions. (37 replies)
- Parts We Skip and Why (50 replies)
- Luthien: Maia or Elf. (22 replies)
- Sam's final journey (27 replies)
- Not just a 'tender of beasts' : Radagast's connection to Slavic Mythology (18 replies)
- gandalf as a maia (55 replies)
- Images of Paradise: comparisons (14 replies)
- Could animals talk? (26 replies)
- tactical discussion, countering balrogs (22 replies)
- bombadils influence on our reading of the narrative (27 replies)
- The Trickster's Consort (37 replies)
- Entwives (10 replies)
- Minas Ithil (9 replies)
- No Living Man (55 replies)
- Tolkien Monster Manual (14 replies)
- Nobility in the books (34 replies)
- Let's Talk Morgoth (81 replies)
- Descent into Hell!!! Rarrr!...Well, sort of... (48 replies)
- Over my dead (gorgeous) body. (10 replies)
- Join the CbC discussion! (48 replies)
- The southerner (4 replies)
- Gongs or Gongers (5 replies)
- Battles of Beleriand (15 replies)
- Himring (4 replies)
vBulletin® v3.8.9 Beta 4, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.